Score: 6

"Nice, but too much bass."

submission: LoZ: Toybox windmill

date: October 17, 2009

Nice sounds, but the bass is too dominant, it hurts my ears to listen to it.

Try turning that down a little, and it should sound a lot better.

Score: 8

"I can find only 3 things wrong with this track."

submission: Fighting - Remake (FF7)

date: August 12, 2009

And I shall list them:

1. The crash cymbals are too loud, they drown out a lot of the song.
2. The horns just before the first set of rising notes should not, in my opinion be staccato. It sounds odd to me.
3. I would really like to hear more of a build up in the rising octaves.

Apart from that, this is totally epic. Great job, particularly the end of the loop.

Score: 6

"It was a'right"

submission: Molasses Punch

date: February 13, 2009

It was quite good to begin with, but then that really high pitched, fast "instrument" came in, and it really did it no justice. The pacing of it was just out, so it sounded as though random notes had been slapped together. Remember that something doesn't have to be impossibly fast to be good.

Score: 4

"Hmmm..."

submission: Pokemon - Lavender Town.

date: January 25, 2009

Really didn't like this. The instruments themselves are fine (except that bass, a bit too much of it). You really caught the wrong mood. You tried to force a sad/slightly haunting melody into a full on halloween special. It really doesn't work. Next time, try not forcing a tune to be something it's not.

Score: 10

"LOL VECTOR!"

submission: Corpse Bride - Vector's Song

date: June 15, 2008

Very well done piece. But I should tell you the difference between 'Victor' and 'Vector'. Victor = a name. Vector = a line with a specific direction (used in maths).

Score: 9

"You're right..."

submission: Layla!

date: June 15, 2008

Even putting this in techno form, which usually wrecks a song, has kept it great! No way you can hurt this. I still prefer the original though, so 9/10 for you.

Score: 6

"It's just the Deku Palace..."

submission: Zmmdeku Nut Palace Rmx Linkfan

date: June 15, 2008

Deku Nut's are the things you throw that flash. Deku Scrubs are the things in the Palace. The track is well done, but the bass sequence is too loud and covers over the melody. And towards the end it just became stupidly wierd.

Score: 9

"Very Nice!"

submission: (::Towards The Sun::) =FINAL=

date: June 15, 2008

Gave it 9 because the soundfonts used weren't the best, but it is very good besides that. The first 5 seconds reminded me of the cave music from Ocarina of Time. Anyway, it's fantastic. 9/10, 5/5

Now review my stuff :P

Score: 6

"Good, Accurate..."

submission: Behind Blue eyes: The Who

date: May 23, 2008

But too synthy. Try with better soundfonts or real instruments. This just sounds like midi with reeverb.

Score: 5

"Not too great..."

submission: Stairway To Heaven....

date: April 2, 2008

It's alright, but the instruments all sound wrong, and it just feels really hollow, not at all the epic masterpiece the original was.

And do not dare to say "I'd like to see you do better" becuase I can do better, I just can't be bothered.

5/10